VST AI Stock Analysis – Buy, Hold, or Avoid?

5 left

Vistra Corp. (VST)

$154.73+1.98 (+1.30%) today

Open
$154.14
High
$158.63
Low
$153.15
Volume
2.23M
Mkt Cap
$52.38B
52W High
$219.82
AI Verdict
Confidence 70%
VSTVistra Corp.
AlphaCrew AI
MIXED
Overall
Summary

Vistra Corp. (VST) presents a complex investment case: while long-term growth opportunities exist from strategic acquisitions and AI-driven demand, recent earnings deterioration, sharp margin compression, and high financial leverage create significant risks. Technicals are bearish and fundamentals have weakened, but sentiment and valuation reflect optimism about future recovery. Investors should be selective and time horizon–sensitive.

By Timeframe
Hover for details
WAIT
Short
HOLD
Medium
HOLD
Long
Agent Signals
32
Fund
Tech
Val
Sent
Risk

Fundamentals

Essentia
Essentia
Fundamental Analysis
MIXED

Vistra Corp. (VST) shows a mixed fundamental picture: after a year of strong profitability and earnings outperformance, 2025 revealed significant revenue and earnings contraction with margin compression and a material miss versus analyst expectations in the latest quarter. While the business model offers defensive characteristics typical for utilities, recent results reflect operational volatility and challenges with cost containment.

Financial Highlights

Q4 2024Q1 2025Q2 2025Q3 2025Q4 2025-$2.5B$0$2.5B$5.0B$7.5BRevenue & Net Income ($)-6%0%6%12%18%Net Margin (%)
  • Revenue
  • Net Income
  • Net Margin (%)

Revenue

$2.34B

-68.24% YoY

Q4 2025

Net Income

$233.00M

-47.17% YoY

Q4 2025

Net Margin

9.97%

Q4 2025

Growth Metrics

Revenue Growth YoY

-68.24%

Latest Quarter: Q4 2025

Net Income Growth YoY

-47.17%

Latest Quarter: Q4 2025

Revenue Per Share Growth YoY

-68.25%

Latest Quarter: Q4 2025

EPS Growth YoY

-52.59%

Latest Quarter: Q4 2025

Book Value Per Share Growth YoY

-8.48%

Latest Quarter: Q4 2025

 Q4 2025Q3 2025Q2 2025Q1 2025Q4 2024Q3 2024Q2 2024Q1 2024
Revenue2.3B5.0B4.3B5.2B7.4B5.5B3.7B2.8B
Revenue Growth YoY-68.24%-10.17%+15.24%+85.14%+117.04%+6.34%+15.61%-25.64%
Net Income233.0M652.0M327.0M-268.0M441.0M1.9B365.0M-35.0M
Net Income Growth YoY-47.17%-65.47%-10.41%-665.71%+339.67%+276.10%-23.32%-105.01%
EPS$0.55$1.78$0.83-$0.93$1.16$5.36$0.92-$0.24
EPS Growth YoY-52.59%-66.79%-9.78%-287.50%+283.63%+322.05%-22.03%-113.95%

Profitability Metrics

Gross Margin

-55.65%

TTM

Operating Margin

-74.76%

TTM

Net Margin

9.97%

TTM

Return on Equity

18.91%

TTM

Return on Assets

2.60%

TTM

 Q4 2025Q3 2025Q2 2025Q1 2025Q4 2024Q3 2024Q2 2024Q1 2024
Gross Margin-55.65%29.89%21.98%29.78%57.35%42.88%26.22%4.69%
Operating Margin-74.76%20.96%12.12%22.57%51.77%35.91%16.73%-6.70%
Net Margin9.97%13.12%7.69%-5.18%5.99%34.12%9.90%-1.25%
Return on Equity (ROE)4.56%12.51%6.78%-5.55%7.92%34.70%6.53%-0.62%
Return on Assets (ROA)0.64%1.97%0.99%-0.81%1.35%5.74%1.08%-0.11%

Technical Analysis

Candela
Candela
Technical Analysis
BEARISH

VST is currently exhibiting a strong downtrend, confirmed by its position below major moving averages and a death cross formation. Momentum indicators are neutral but overall weak, indicating the stock is range-bound with bearish bias. Traders should be cautious as the stock remains in a declining phase without clear reversal signals.

RSI
Hold
Neutral48

No extreme reading

03070100
Trend
Sell
Strong Downtrend

Price in downtrend

-14.2% from 200 SMA
ADX
Hold
Weak/No Trend17

Range-bound market

Weak
MA Cross
Sell
Below 50/200

50 below 200 - bearish

50
200

Key Technical Values

Price
$154.73
50 SMA
$159.84
150 SMA
$175.18
200 SMA
$180.26
52W High
$219.82
52W Low
$99.24

Price with Moving Averages

50-day, 150-day and 200-day simple moving averages

Price
50 SMA
150 SMA
200 SMA

Relative Strength Index

Momentum oscillator measuring speed and magnitude of price changes

RSI (14)

≤30 Oversold
≥70 Overbought
48Neutral

Earnings

Essentia
Essentia
Fundamental Analysis
MIXED

Vistra Corp. (VST) shows a mixed fundamental picture: after a year of strong profitability and earnings outperformance, 2025 revealed significant revenue and earnings contraction with margin compression and a material miss versus analyst expectations in the latest quarter. While the business model offers defensive characteristics typical for utilities, recent results reflect operational volatility and challenges with cost containment.

Latest Earnings

Q4 2025 Earnings (Dec 31, 2025)

Earnings Per Share (EPS)

Miss

Actual

$0.54

Estimated

$2.31

Surprise

$-1.77

Surprise %

-76.49%

Revenue

Miss

Actual

$4.58B

Estimated

$5.79B

Surprise

-$1.21B

Surprise %

-20.82%

Historical Earnings

 Q4 2025Q3 2025Q2 2025Q1 2025Q4 2024Q3 2024Q2 2024Q1 2024
Earnings Per Share
EPS (Actual)$0.54$1.75$0.81$-0.93$1.14$5.40$0.90$0.23
EPS (Estimated)$2.31$2.08$0.88$0.54$0.85$1.20$1.38$0.62
EPS Surprise-$1.77-$0.33-$0.06-$1.47+$0.29+$4.20-$0.48-$0.39
% Diff-76.5%-15.9%-7.4%-273.5%+34.1%+350.0%-34.8%-62.8%
Revenue
Revenue (Actual)$4.58B$4.97B$4.25B$5.17B$7.36B$5.53B$3.69B$2.79B
Revenue (Estimated)$5.79B$6.11B$4.74B$4.55B$3.91B$5.01B$3.96B$2.92B
Revenue Surprise-$1.21B-$1.14B-$494.46M+$622.8M+$3.45B+$521.6M-$276.37M-$130.48M
% Diff-20.8%-18.7%-10.4%+13.7%+88.1%+10.4%-7.0%-4.5%

Valuation

Valorem
Valorem
Valuation Analysis
FAIRLY VALUED

Vistra Corp (VST) currently trades at elevated multiples reflective of transitional industry dynamics and recent acquisition impacts, with a strong analyst consensus supporting significant upside potential. While the stock is technically in a short-term bearish trend, fundamentals indicate improving profitability and stable cash flow amid sector challenges. Valuation appears rich on trailing metrics but discounted on forward outlook, suggesting nuanced investor sentiment.

Valuation Metrics

Price to Earnings

55.70

TTM

Price to Sales

3.13

TTM

Price to Book

10.29

TTM

Enterprise Value to EBITDA

14.72

TTM

Enterprise Value to Revenue

4.30

TTM

 Q4 2025Q3 2025Q2 2025Q1 2025Q4 2024Q3 2024Q2 2024Q1 2024
Price to Earnings58.8225.5350.29-37.2326.555.3820.76-178.30
Price to Sales23.4513.3915.487.726.367.358.228.94
Price to Book10.7312.7813.648.278.417.475.424.41
Enterprise Value to EBITDA57.0544.7174.5795.2140.3416.5730.4052.22
Enterprise Value to Revenue31.8216.7919.6211.038.5610.0412.3714.43

Sentiment & Analyst Ratings

Pulse
Pulse
Sentiment Analysis
MIXED

Vistra Corp. (VST) currently experiences predominantly positive sentiment driven by strong analyst buy ratings and optimistic projections fueled by AI-powered demand growth and strategic acquisitions. Despite recent earnings misses and insider selling contributing some caution, the overall market buzz and institutional confidence remain solid, underpinned by upgraded credit ratings and robust dividend increases.

Analyst Recommendations

As of Apr 1, 2026
Strong SellSellHoldBuyStrong Buy
Buy
4.0 / 5.0
Based on 20 analyst ratings
Strong Sell
1
Sell
0
Hold
0
Buy
15
Strong Buy
4

Risk Assessment

Sentinel
Sentinel
Risk Assessment
HIGH

Vistra Corp. (VST) exhibits significant financial leverage and liquidity challenges, with a deteriorating ability to cover short-term liabilities and strained debt service metrics. The company operates in a competitive and regulatory-sensitive utilities sector marked by commodity price volatility and evolving market interventions. While recent acquisitions and AI infrastructure positioning offer growth opportunities, elevated financial and operational risks remain present.

Liquidity & Solvency

Current Ratio

0.78

Latest Quarter: Q4 2025

Quick Ratio

0.69

Latest Quarter: Q4 2025

Debt-to-Equity

3.99

Latest Quarter: Q4 2025

Debt-to-Assets

0.49

Latest Quarter: Q4 2025

 Q4 2025Q3 2025Q2 2025Q1 2025Q4 2024Q3 2024Q2 2024Q1 2024
Liquidity Metrics
Current Ratio0.780.990.900.860.961.110.981.07
Quick Ratio0.690.880.800.770.850.990.880.96
Solvency Metrics
Debt-to-Equity3.993.363.743.673.122.913.032.90
Debt-to-Assets0.490.460.470.460.460.420.430.43

Liquidity Assessment

Current Ratio: 0.78(Weak)

Quick Ratio: 0.69(Weak)

The company has relatively weak liquidity and may face challenges meeting short-term obligations.

Solvency Assessment

Debt-to-Equity: 3.99(High)

Debt-to-Assets: 0.49(Moderate)

The company has relatively high debt levels, which may increase financial risk in economic downturns.

Frequently Asked Questions about VST

AI Answers: Common Questions About VST

Get AI-powered answers to the questions investors ask most about Vistra Corp.

VST is not a compelling buy right now: its P/E is 72.3 (well above sector), recent earnings have collapsed (EPS down from $7.16 to $2.21), and the stock is in a downtrend below all major moving averages. While analyst targets are high, the current operational and financial profile does not justify aggressive entry.

If you own VST, consider holding rather than selling unless the $150 support decisively breaks or liquidity/earnings deteriorate further. The technicals are weak and fundamentals have worsened, but sentiment and sector catalysts may support a future rebound.

The biggest risks are high financial leverage (debt/equity near 4x), deteriorating liquidity (current ratio ~0.78, quick ratio <0.7), and sharp earnings/margin contraction (net margin down to 5.6%). Regulatory, commodity, and integration risks add further downside potential.

Key support is at $150, with downside risk to the $99-103 range if that fails. Resistance is at $160 (50 SMA), $175 (150 SMA), and $180 (200 SMA). Analyst targets range from $212 to $293, but these assume a turnaround not yet visible in fundamentals or technicals.

The stock is richly valued on trailing metrics (P/E 72.3, high EV/EBITDA, elevated P/S), but forward P/E and PEG suggest some improvement if earnings rebound. Current valuation is only justified if future growth materializes; otherwise, it is expensive relative to sector norms.

Fundamentals are currently weak: revenue fell 12.4% in 2025, net income dropped 64%, and gross margin compressed to 17.5%. Cash flow and earnings quality are concerns, and the balance sheet is strained by high leverage and low liquidity.

Technical analysis is bearish: price is below all major moving averages, a death cross is active, RSI is neutral but momentum is weak, and the stock is in a Stage 4 downtrend. A break below $150 could trigger further declines toward $99-103.

Key catalysts include upcoming earnings reports (potential for positive surprise if cost controls succeed), integration progress from the Cogentrix acquisition, and realization of AI/data center demand growth. Macro events like commodity price shifts and regulatory changes also matter.

Want a Personalized Answer?

Get AI-powered insights tailored to your risk tolerance and investment goals.

More AI Stock Analyses